CVE-2026-55493

HotCRP: comment-author search exposes anonymous commenter identities

Published Oct 30, 2026 CVSS 3.1 · 6.5 Medium EPSS < 1% KEV · Not listed
Description
HotCRP is conference review software. Starting with 2.101, the `cmt:` search term checks whether a comment is visible to the searching user but fails to check whether the commenter's identity should be visible. A `cmt:USER` search can therefore match a paper with a visible comment authored by USER even when the comment is supposed to be anonymous. An authenticated user with access to the search can infer the author of an anonymous comment, compromising reviewer anonymity. Comments that the user cannot see remain excluded from search results. The advisory prose identifies 3.3 as fixed, its affected-version metadata excludes 3.3, and the verified repository tag 3.3 already contains the identity-check fix; however, its patched-version metadata instead lists 3.3.1. This fixed-version source conflict remains unresolved.

Analysis

AI-generated

Technical impact

HotCRP's comment search function, introduced in version 2.101, evaluates whether a comment is visible to the searching user but fails to confirm whether the commenter's identity should be visible. As a result, a search query in the form of "cmt:USER" can return papers that contain a visible comment authored by USER, even when that comment is intended to remain anonymous. This flaw enables an authenticated user with search access to infer the identity of an otherwise anonymous reviewer, thereby breaching the confidentiality promised by the anonymity feature. The weakness is an Authorization flaw classified as CWE‑863.

Affected Systems

The vulnerability affects all released versions of HotCRP from 2.101 through the pre‑3.3 releases. The official advisory indicates that HotCRP v3.3 includes the fix, with the patched version also listed as 3.3.1, resolving the identity‑check issue. The affected vendor is Kohler, product HotCRP.

Risk and Exploitability

With a CVSS score of 6.5, the vulnerability presents a moderate severity threat. The EPSS score is not available, and the issue is not listed in the CISA KEV catalog. Exploitation requires an authenticated user who can perform a search against the system; the attacker must possess at least baseline search permissions but does not need elevated privileges. Once the attacker logs in, a simple search query can reveal an anonymous commenter's identity, compromising evaluator anonymity without any need for code execution or other complex attack steps.

Remediation

No solution or workaround provided in the CVE record.

OpenCVE Recommended Actions

  • Upgrade HotCRP to version 3.3 or later, which contains the identity‑check fix for comment search queries.
  • Configure search permissions so that only users with legitimate review or administrative responsibilities can execute "cmt:" queries, reducing the surface for identity discovery.
  • Re‑evaluate and tighten reviewer anonymity settings to ensure that comments intended as anonymous remain inaccessible to search operations by non‑authorized users.

Generated by OpenCVE AI on October 30, 2026 at 20:20 UTC.

Tracking

Sign in to view the affected projects.

Advisories

No advisories available
History
Type Values Removed Values Added
Metrics ssvc

{'options': {'Automatable': 'no', 'Exploitation': 'none', 'Technical Impact': 'partial'}, 'version': '2.0.3'}

Type Values Removed Values Added
First Time appeared Kohler
Kohler hotcrp
Vendors & Products Kohler
Kohler hotcrp
Type Values Removed Values Added
Description HotCRP is conference review software. Starting with 2.101, the `cmt:` search term checks whether a comment is visible to the searching user but fails to check whether the commenter's identity should be visible. A `cmt:USER` search can therefore match a paper with a visible comment authored by USER even when the comment is supposed to be anonymous. An authenticated user with access to the search can infer the author of an anonymous comment, compromising reviewer anonymity. Comments that the user cannot see remain excluded from search results. The advisory prose identifies 3.3 as fixed, its affected-version metadata excludes 3.3, and the verified repository tag 3.3 already contains the identity-check fix; however, its patched-version metadata instead lists 3.3.1. This fixed-version source conflict remains unresolved.
Title HotCRP: comment-author search exposes anonymous commenter identities
Weaknesses CWE-863
References
Metrics cvssV3_1

{'score': 6.5, 'vector': 'CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:N/A:N'}

Weaknesses

Sources

Status
PUBLISHED
Assigner
GitHub_M
Published
Updated
Nov 5, 2026, 2:32 AM
Reserved
Jun 16, 2026, 10:28 PM
Status
Deferred
Published
Oct 30, 2026, 8:17 PM
Modified
Nov 5, 2026, 3:17 AM